are we too right-wing for time travel?
Despite what a majority of you probably thought when you saw the title - especially those who know me well - this is not a post about the approaching September episode of Doctor Who entitled 'Let's Kill Hitler'. Nor is it an open letter to Quentin Tarantino, telling him... well I won't spoil the end of Inglorious Bastards for those who haven't seen it (although I've clearly already given it away.) It is, actually, a blog about why you shouldn't kill Hitler....
There are a lot of people in this world who have no imagination. Regrettably, most of these creatively inept people have formspring accounts. So quite frequently, the same same, unimaginative, uninteresting questions appear in your inbox. Examples being: 'what's your favourite band?', 'What came first, the chicken or the egg?', 'U R GAY!' But there's one question that keeps coming up, and it's not the question that bothers me, so much have how so many people choose to answer it. The question is 'If you could go back in time, where would you go, and what would you do?'... Now, there's nothing wrong with this question, but 90% of time, I see it being answerd with 'I'd kill Hitler'
Now, don't take this the wrong way, I hate Hitler too.I'm no Hitler fan. And I, like most, wish that Hitler had never been born .Or had never got it to power. However I do strongly believe that killing Hitler, by means of time travel, would be a bad idea. Now I can see where, at this point you might disagree with me. You might think that,by killing Hitler, you'd save the lives of ten million people murderd in the holocaust, and all the soldiers -on both sides- who lost their lives. Well, you'd be right. But that's not the point. Imagine a young couple in love, living in 1930s Britain. But before long the boy gets called to war, were he's eventually shot to death in occupied France. The girl grieves, for a while, and then moves on and starts a family with someone else. Now if you were to kill Hitler, she would have stayed with boy one, who would have never went to war, and they'd have lived happily ever after. The romantics may fail to see what I'm getting at here, but if she hadn't have met boy 2 , she never would have had that family. In your return to 2011 you'd find that the children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren for the girl, would have never been. Now imagine this a thousand times over. You may return to the present day to find that your friend, wife, husband, boss or fiancée. No longer exist. As well, all the great films, paintings, literature and poems derived from the war, have all also vanished. Culture will be completely different, relationships with other nations will be weaker, no Winston Churchills or George Pattons to be idolised and Anti-Semitism maybe still running strong in the national consensus.
This is what worries me about time travel , not all the complicated paradoxes about killing your granddad or sleeping with your mother. But man's inability to think past his macho-conservative attitude, and use time travel as a way to go back and kill everyone he disagrees with. It's not just benevolent dictators that are in danger either. What's to stop the Pope from going back in time and killing Mohamed and L. Ron Hubbard and every other prophet, making Christianity the only religion on the planet?
As much as I would love to experience time travel in our lifetime, I'm quite glad it's far beyond our reach. Hopefully, one day, when our race is far far past it's killing people phase, then we can have time travel. When it'll be used only for learning and recreation, and not as a weapon.
Hi, you probably don't remember me but this is @gryffindorky off of twitter.. except I kind of don't go on there any more... Anyhow during my bored stumblings through facebook I came across this and I thought I'd share a few thoughts :)
ReplyDeleteFirstly, you're a nerdfighter, right? Did you get inspiration for this blog from the Evil Baby Orphanage thing perchance? ;)
Secondly, while forward timetravel is perfectly possible, (we're travelling forward in time right now, and can travel faster forward with the use of very high speed ie. close to the speed of light) you shouldn't worry too much about the consequences of travelling back in time because, as far as science is concerned, it's impossible. On top of lots of causality related problems, it would actually break the first law of thermodynamics/law of conservation of energy. Even though I'm a DW fan.. the Beeb haven't got it quite right.. ;)
Thirdly, 'What came first, the chicken or the egg?' is actually one of my favourite questions, I have quite an extensive answer to it as opposed to the usual one word answers given.. yes I am that nerdy :L I won't make this comment any bigger with it though.
Lastly, just thought I'd let you know these blogs are very well written, do some more soon please :) Also, long time no speak, how are you?
Sorry about this essay of a comment :L x
Of course I remember. lol. I've been meaning to ask you for a while why you don't use titter any more.
ReplyDeleteI might have subconsciously drew inspiration from the vlogbrothers, that's very possible.
Also, that for the reassuring me that nobodies going to be able to kill Hitler. I love science, it's so comforting.
Crap. Basically I just wrote a longish response about the whole twitter thing and now it's gone, so here's a (probably not so) short version:
ReplyDeleteIn the end I was just using twitter for people to cheer me up when I was feeling crap and I didn't want that all over the internet anymore, where people I know IRL can see it, hence why I put it on private.
Also talking about aspects of my personal life with people I don't actually know weirded me out just a little too much in the end. It was partially to do with getting over something irl which kind of went with twitter because I talked about it to people so much but I'm not gonna go into that.
I do really miss chatting to everyone, it was really fun and I would come back but I think I spent far too much time on it, twitter is very good procrastination which is VERY bad for me :L
Maybe if you try and persuade me I might just try it again? ;)
Ok, I'll gather up people on twitter who want you back and we'll picket outside you're house ;P
ReplyDeleteIf anything, you should *at least* come back when Doctor Who when starts again.
Might take you a while to get here :P
ReplyDeleteI might post randomly every so often and see who notices that I'm 'back', but shhh, don't tell anyone ;)